When it comes to pickleball paddles, two names typically face off for the title and that is: Joola vs Selkirk.
These brands aren’t just pickleball leaders—they’re the titans of the sport, each vying for the title of the best paddle maker in pickleball.
If you’ve been around the game even for a short while, you’ve probably asked yourself the big question: “Which is better—Joola or Selkirk?”
Both brands have their loyal fans. They both have impressive features. But the truth is, they are pretty different.
Joola is the tech-savvy newcomer (with a deep background in table tennis), known for innovation and spin-friendly paddles. Selkirk, on the other hand, is the seasoned veteran, delivering American-made quality and unmatched durability.
So, which pickleball brand is the right fit for you?
Let’s break it all down, head-to-head, and see if we can settle this once and for all.
The Battle Just Got Personal: Joola vs. Selkirk
Tyson McGuffin is a household name in pickleball. He’s been one of the sport’s most recognizable faces, and for the past decade, he’s been synonymous with Selkirk. For 10 years, he played, competed, and won under the Selkirk banner, becoming a true ambassador for the brand.
And then, pretty much out of nowhere, Tyson dropped a bombshell: he was parting ways with Selkirk.
The pickleball world went wild. Me Included. I was shocked.
And then, Tyson McGuffin signed with Joola Pickleball, Selkirk’s biggest competitor.
While the details of his contract remain private, the pickleball rumor mill hasn’t stopped spinning. Word on the street is that this deal is huge—the second-largest in pickleball history, only behind Ben Johns’ lifetime contract with Joola in early 2023.
Yes, lifetime.
Think about that.
Now Joola has two of the biggest names in men’s pickleball—Ben Johns and Tyson McGuffin—on their roster. These rivals who battle it out on the court are now part of the same team.
Will we see them in marketing campaigns together?
Or are they more likely to stay in their own lanes, paddling their separate ways under the Joola brand?
Either way, one thing’s for sure: Tyson’s move cements Joola’s position as a powerhouse in the pickleball world. And yes, in the deal Tyson gets his own signature Joola paddle.
Check out this video below talking about Ben Johns’ lifetime contract with Joola.
The Brands at a Glance: Joola vs. Selkirk
Let’s take a step back and look at the bigger picture.
Tyson’s move is exciting, but it’s just the latest chapter in the rivalry between Joola and Selkirk. Both brands bring their A-game, but they do it in different ways.
Joola: The Innovator
Joola is like that flashy new player who shows up to open play and dominates right away.
Originally a big name in table tennis, Joola exploded onto the pickleball scene with innovative designs and aggressive pro signings. They’re all about performance—textured paddle faces for spin, lightweight materials for speed, and sleek designs that scream “game-changer.”
And let’s not forget their roster of superstars. With names like Ben Johns, Anna Bright, Collin Johns, Simone Jardim, and now Tyson McGuffin, Joola isn’t just making paddles—they’re building a dynasty.
Selkirk: Made in the USA, Built to Last
Selkirk is kind of like the OG in the pickleball world. They’ve been around for years, setting the standard for paddle quality and durability.
But what really sets Selkirk apart?
Every paddle is made in the USA.
This isn’t just a tagline—it’s a commitment to craftsmanship. Selkirk takes pride in building paddles with precision and care, ensuring that every product meets the highest standards. And with their lifetime warranty, they stand behind their work like no other brand.
Selkirk’s paddles are trusted by players of all levels, from weekend warriors to pros like Riley Newman and Catherine Parenteau. They might have lost Tyson, but their reputation as a reliable, American-made brand is stronger than ever.
The Vibe Check
Here’s how I like to think about it:
- Joola feels like the cool, tech-savvy up-and-comer with a focus on innovation and style.
- Selkirk is the dependable hometown hero, proudly flying the “Made in the USA” flag and delivering unmatched quality.
Neither is “better” across the board—it’s all about what you value in a pickleball paddle.
Next, let’s dig into what really matters: How do their pickleball paddles compare on the court? Spin, power, control, and durability—we’re covering it all in the next section!
Key Pickleball Paddle Comparisons: Spin, Power, Control, and Durability
So, how do Joola and Selkirk pickleball paddles actually perform on the pickleball court? Let’s break it down by the features that matter most.
Spin and Control
When it comes to spin, Joola is the undisputed king.
Their paddles often feature textured surfaces, like carbon-forged faces or grit coatings, designed to maximize spin. If you’re the type of player who loves to rip topspin drives or slice your way to victory, Joola’s paddles are built for you.
Selkirk paddles, on the other hand, prioritize consistency over flair. While they might not have the same gritty texture as Joola, their smooth surfaces provide excellent control and precision. If you’re all about placement—dropping that third shot right where you want it—Selkirk’s paddles are a dream.
Power and Sweet Spot
This one’s a toss-up, depending on your playstyle.
Selkirk’s thicker cores (like the ones in their Vanguard and Power Air series) deliver serious power. These paddles pack a punch and have a forgiving sweet spot, making them ideal for players who like to crush the ball while still maintaining consistency.
Joola paddles, on the other hand, tend to lean toward finesse and speed. Their lightweight designs make them great for quick hands at the net, but they might not hit quite as hard as Selkirk when it comes to raw power.
Durability
Here’s where Selkirk’s Made in the USA advantage really shines.
With their lifetime warranty, Selkirk paddles are built to last. Whether you’re playing four hours a day or accidentally tossing your paddle out of frustration (we’ve all been there), you can count on Selkirk to hold up.
Joola paddles are durable too, but their focus is more on performance tech. While they don’t offer a lifetime warranty, their paddles are still designed to withstand heavy use.
Specific Paddle Showdown
Here’s a quick look at two of their standout models:
- Joola Hyperion CFS 16: Known for its spin-friendly surface and balanced weight, this paddle is perfect for players who want control and finesse with just enough power to finish points.
- Selkirk Vanguard Power Air: A beast when it comes to power, with a large sweet spot and great touch around the net. Plus, it’s 100% made in the USA.
The Takeaway
- If you’re a spin fanatic who loves to slice and dice, Joola has your back.
- If you’re a power player who values durability and an all-American build, Selkirk is calling your name.
But at the end of the day, the paddle that’s “better” is the one that feels right in your hand. The best way to know? Try them both and see which one fits your style.
Which Paddle Is Right for YOU?
Choosing between Joola and Selkirk can feel like picking sides in the ultimate pickleball showdown. But the truth is, the best paddle depends on your skill level, playing style, and personal preferences. Let’s break it down.
For Beginners: Keep It Simple
If you’re new to the game, you’ll want a paddle that’s easy to use and forgiving.
- Selkirk paddles, like the SLK series, are a great choice for beginners. They’re balanced, reliable, and won’t overwhelm you with too much spin or complexity. Plus, the lifetime warranty gives you peace of mind as you learn the ropes.
- Joola, while known for its innovation, might be better suited for players with a little more experience. Their paddles tend to focus on performance features like spin and finesse, which might not be as useful for beginners just getting comfortable on the court.
For Spin Enthusiasts: Slice and Dice
Do you love ripping topspin serves or carving insane angles with your dinks?
This is where Joola shines. Their textured paddle surfaces, like the ones on the Ben Johns Hyperion series, are designed to maximize spin. If you want to frustrate your opponents with crazy ball movement, Joola is your go-to.
Selkirk paddles provide good control for spin, but their smoother surfaces don’t generate the same level of bite. They’re more about consistency and touch than outright spin wizardry.
For Power Players: Bring the Heat
If your game is all about hard drives and aggressive put-aways, Selkirk paddles are a powerhouse.
Models like the Vanguard Power Air or the Invikta deliver serious pop. Their thicker cores and solid construction make them ideal for players who want to dominate with power.
Joola paddles can still pack a punch, but their focus is often more on control and finesse. If you’re a power player, Selkirk might feel more like home.
For All-Around Players: Balance Is Key
If you’re someone who likes to mix it up—drives, drops, dinks, and everything in between—you can’t go wrong with either brand.
- Selkirk’s Vanguard Hybrid is a fantastic all-around paddle with a large sweet spot and great touch.
- Joola’s Hyperion CFS 16 offers a nice balance of spin, control, and just enough power to keep your opponents guessing.
For the Obsessed: Try Both
Let’s be honest—pickleball players are always looking for their next paddle upgrade. If you’re a gear junkie, the best advice is to demo both brands and see what feels right in your hand.
Because at the end of the day, it’s not just about the paddle. It’s about how it matches your game.
The Bottom Line
- Beginners: Start simple with Selkirk.
- Spin lovers: Go for Joola.
- Power players: Unleash your game with Selkirk.
- All-arounders: Flip a coin or try them both—you can’t lose.
The Final Rally: Joola vs. Selkirk
So, where does that leave us in the great Joola vs. Selkirk debate?
Both brands bring serious game to the court. Joola is all about innovation, spin, and making waves with high-profile signings like Ben Johns and Tyson McGuffin. Meanwhile, Selkirk stands tall as the reliable, all-American choice with unmatched durability and power-packed paddles.
At the end of the day, the “better” paddle is the one that fits your game. Whether you’re slinging spin with a Joola or smashing winners with a Selkirk, it’s all about finding what feels good in your hand and makes you confident on the court.
Your Turn: Team Joola or Team Selkirk?
Now it’s time to hear from you! Are you Team Joola, ready to spin your way to victory? Or Team Selkirk, proud to rep a paddle made in the USA?
Drop a comment below and let me know which side you’re on—and why. And if you’re still on the fence, there’s no better excuse to hit the court and try them both.
Because no matter what paddle you choose, one thing’s for sure: pickleball is always a win.
